|
Author: Rosanna Cooper Article source: http://www.rtcoopers.com/. Used with author's permission.
Marketing Authorisation: Medicinal Products The case of R (on the application of Merck Sharp and Dohme Ltd) v Licensing Authority [2005], concerned the application for marketing authorisation for a generic product which was based on Product C (see below).
The claimant had marketing authorisations for three medicinal products used in the treatment of osteoporosis and three generic companies sought marketing authorisation for Product C.
Product A - was authorised by the European Community in 1993;
Product B - was authorised in 2000
Product C - was a generic product based on Product B (a copy of Product B).
When a company applies for marketing authorisation for a product, it is a requirement under the European Parliament and Council Directive (EC) 2001/83 (the "Directive"), to supply a full set of data in order to show the safety and efficacy of the product.
There are instances under the Directive when an applicant can simply rely on data submitted in respect of a previously authorised product. For instance, the applicant could refer to data already submitted in respect of a product with marketing authorisation, where the applicant is seeking authorisation for a product 'essentially similar' to a product holding a marketing authorisation for ten years (as per the United Kingdom and pursuant to art 10(i)(a)(iii) of the Directive).
In seeking marketing authorisation for Product C, the generic companies relied on data submitted in relation to Product A and Product B. However, although Product A and Product B contained the same active ingredient, they were not 'essentially similar' within the meaning of the Directive. This meant that they differed in respect of their posology (the schedule of dosage). The defendant accepted that the generic companies did not have to provide any further data but the claimant argued that such an approach was unlawful and in breach of the Directive. The claimant made a reference to the European Court of Justice ("Court of Justice").
The claimant contended that the issue was as yet unresolved by the rules laid down in previous decisions of the ECJ. In particular, it was argued, that there had been no cases where a difference in posology had been the subject of a decision.
The application was dismissed. The ECJ held that:
The principles laid down by the ECJ in earlier decisions were clearly applicable in this case and there was no uncertainty;
Although it was true that a change in posology had not previously been the subject of a decision, it was for the ECJ to interpret the EC Treaty and the relevant principles by which it was to be interpreted, and for the domestic court to apply those principles to the particular case.
No new principles arose in the instant case.
If you require further information contact us.
Email: enquiries@rtcoopers.com
© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances. Rosanna Cooper is a partner in RT Coopers Solicitors a full service law firm in London. The firm specialises in patents, trade marks, copyright, designs, technology transfer, biotechnology and pharmaceutical law. The firm has a flexible approach to fees and provides the highest quality legal advice.
Contact us at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. visit our website at http://www.rtcoopers.com
Why Your ISP Takes Bribes From Spammers
The lifeblood of the spammer is email. They need to be able to send lots of it on an ongoing basis to stay in "business". High profile spammers can send 80 mill...
MLM Recruiting- The 5 Cs of MLM Recruiting in Network Marketing
The 5 C's of MLM Recruiting came from a 14 month study of the industry by PassionFire International.Do you know these powerful triats of millionaire recruiters?...
Best Writing Advice I Ever Got
Veteran author offers hints to writers of all ages...
Womens Sexual Health is Nothing to Worry About When You Use this Powerful Natural Medicine
Our inability to diagnose and solve female sexual problems will haunt women's sexual health, as long as women are looking for a quick fix in the form of a libid...
Hiring the Right People for a Luxury Pet Boutique
People will always be the number one reason that sales continue to grow. Therefore, hiring the right people will be critical to the growth and profitability of...
10 Interesting Facts about Archangel Michael
Michael is considered the greatest angel in the Christian, Judaic and Islamic traditions, and is a powerful source of inspiration and enlightenment.
Strength Training After Fifty
Gives older adults a direction with strength training. What they should look for and what they should aquire before lifting a single pound.
New York City Laser Hair Removal
We spend a lot of time waxing, cutting, shaving, plucking away hair from unwanted places like legs, upper lip, chin, arms, back, and other such areas, only to f...
What Do You Really, Really, Really Want?
If the 90s British pop sensation 'the Spice Girls' ever get remembered for anything, I hope it's for bringing the question 'now tell me what you want, what you ...
Credit Card Vs. Debit Card - What Are The Main Differences
With our electronical cards fortunately the days of the mad rush and long queues to get cash from the bank before weekends are long gone. We now enjoy the conve...
A Guide to Vinyl Shutters
Vinyl shutters are much less expensive than their wooden counterparts. They offer other benefits, as well. Vinyl is better able to withstand the abuses of time ...
7 Simple Steps to Financial Freedom and Wealth Building - Step 2
Do you want to achieve financial freedom? For most people, this is constantly on their mind. If you are reading CashFlow Avenue's 7 Simple Steps to Financial Fr...
What Is RSS?
Recently I did an interview with a well known email Internet Marketer. He wanted to share with his readers a viewpoint on what RSS is from someone who is using ...
All Faith Needs Feet
Faith is a wonderful thing - and very necessary. There are, however, approaches that may look like faith but lead us in risky directions.
Vary Your Writing Style and Win Readers
Fact: readers are put to sleep if your writing begins to 'drone'. Vary your sentence beginnings, your sentence length and your sentence structure - and watch y...
Organization, the Key to Success
One of the biggest things you can do to make any business successful is to be organized. Organization helps you work faster, more efficiently, helps you to por...
Nature, An ADHD Natural Treatment
My mother's warning; "You are going to rot your brain out..." still rings through my mind whenever I spend too much time in front of the television set. I grew ...
Why Real Estate Agents Need Their Own Website
It is difficult, if not impossible, for a real estate agent to be successful today without a Website. This article examines the reasons that Realtors require a...
How to Write Press Releases That Work And Get Free Publicity
Anyone can learn to write press releases. It just takes a little knowledge and a lot of practice. The tips in this article will teach you what you need to know ...
Secrets Of Aromatherapy Part I - Physical Remedies
Aromatherapy can be used to relieve the discomfort of a
wide range of minor physical complaints including burns,
colds, flu, sinus problems, cold sores, eczema,...
Avoid, Shun, Thwart, Prevent, and then Filter Spam
Whether you're a seasoned professional looking for a refresher course, or you're new to the internet and email and want to start off right, here are some easy s...
Marriage Counseling Tips: What to Do When Your Spouse Wont Talk
What can you do if your spouse won't talk to you in spite of everything you've tried? This article presents tips designed to jumpstart your thinking about creat...
The Easy Secrets To Determine Stock Market Position Sizing
When trading in the stock market, position sizing is where all the tools of money management come together.
Compulsive Eating and Binge Eating Disaster Plan
Sometimes good intentions alone aren't enough to overpower the urge to binge. This is where positive desire needs to be coupled with a sound plan. Willpower alo...
|
Print this page